GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 569818
subtitles editing track
Last modified: 2015-10-20 13:28:15 UTC
Example use case: for the PiTiVi tutorial, I intend to make me and the computer talk, both in English (both not our native languages!), and some viewers may have trouble understanding our respective acccents. Here is a nifty idea to make PiTiVi a killer NLE: integrate the workflow of subtitling: allow adding "subtitle" tracks. Those tracks would be a third kind of track (vs audio tracks and video tracks). They would allow only one specific kind of clip to be inserted in it, that is, a "subtitle clip". Each subtitle clip would behave like a generic clip in the sense that you can move it left and right on the timeline and trim its starting/ending point by dragging its left/right edges. Selecting the clip would reveal a small gtk.entry (or text field?) below the timeline that allows editing the text (no dialog, that would be overkill). The text would be plain-text, so nothing complicated on that front; we want this to be compatible with plaintext subtitle formats. Creating subtitles would be simple: the user can click a button and a subtitle clip would be added to the current subtitle track, at the cursor position. If no such button is available, an alternate way (which is just as easy, but needs to be documented for end-users) is that to add a subtitle clip, you select a region of the subtitle track and start typing directly. In the end, the user has two choices: - export a subtitle track manually, to .srt or something - render the project, with a container format that embeds those subtitles (such as mkv, and perhaps ogv and mp4?) Subtitles should take into account ripple/rollover edits, I guess.
Use Case: I used gtk-RecordMyDesktop to produce a video tour of an application, without audio. I now want to create subtitles for the video, and cut/delay the video as needed to match the script. The only way to do this currently is to make an .srt file in Subtitle Editor, and switch back and forth with PITIVI to tweak and edit the video. Being able to edit a subtitle track directly within PITIVI would be very powerful.
This will not happen without a patch, and it's not going to be trivial so I can't tag this gnome-love.
*** Bug 585131 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
*** Bug 736225 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
> If you're looking to hardcode/burn subtitles in the picture No. I want that subtitles are the same editable tracks as video and audio. > If you're looking to readjust srt files and such Probably subtitle editor really would be better preferred to synchronize subtitles. But there is another examples of using subtitles in video editor: 1) Dubbing films by subtitles (Amateur actors dubbing experiencing an acute shortage of support SRT. They have to make hardsub. 2) Editing video, audio, subtitles (eg make cuts favorite movie or TV series with multiple audio tracks and subtitles). MKVToolnix able to do it, but there is no preview and cutting only by keyframe. This feature request was discussed also here https://forum.kde.org/viewtopic.php?f=265&t=122747 http://www.kdenlive.org/mantis/view.php?id=3362
This bug has been migrated to https://phabricator.freedesktop.org/T2006. Please use the Phabricator interface to report further bugs by creating a task and associating it with Project: Pitivi. See http://wiki.pitivi.org/wiki/Bug_reporting for details.