GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 762314
The review buttons (was useful yes/no/report abuse) have too much importance
Last modified: 2016-02-25 17:01:21 UTC
Created attachment 321646 [details] screenshot of the UI Using current git on Ubuntu, while looking at the review section what feels the most visible/put in front to me are the buttons "yes"/"no"/"report abuse". It might be because everything else is flat and they are quite noticeable compared to the rest of the UI? In any case reporting an abuse is not the most common action I would expect from users on that page (neither are stating if the review was useful), they are probably rather interested in reading the actual reviews. Would it make sense to maybe have the buttons smallers or use "url style label" (e.g color/underlined text)?
(In reply to Sebastien Bacher from comment #0) ... > Using current git on Ubuntu, while looking at the review section what feels > the most visible/put in front to me are the buttons "yes"/"no"/"report > abuse". > > It might be because everything else is flat and they are quite noticeable > compared to the rest of the UI? It's probably also because of the placement of the buttons - they stick out into the middle of the page. It would be really useful to have a screenshot of a bigger window with more reviews visible (I tried to do this, but don't have access to many reviews currently). > In any case reporting an abuse is not the most common action I would expect > from users on that page (neither are stating if the review was useful), they > are probably rather interested in reading the actual reviews. Would it make > sense to maybe have the buttons smallers or use "url style label" (e.g > color/underlined text)? Smaller buttons is certainly a possibility, yes.
Created attachment 321946 [details] new screenshot with some more reviews
Okay, new button style is fixed in: commit 013999a8318809d90b389b56076a536973a06980 Author: Richard Hughes <richard@hughsie.com> Date: Tue Feb 23 16:06:52 2016 +0000 Show a confirmation dialog before reporting a review This matches the new mockups from Allan. :100644 100644 496ca4f... 4ca4989... M src/gs-review-row.c :100644 100644 b018f91... f825baf... M src/gs-review-row.ui :100644 100644 79b6224... 8f30f14... M src/gtk-style.css
(In reply to Sebastien Bacher from comment #2) > Created attachment 321946 [details] > new screenshot with some more reviews Thanks Seb! We spent a while discussing this on #gnome-design today, and we all agreed that it was an issue. Hopefully the fix will help.
The fix makes those less intrusive, but they display as normal text now, no pointer change on mouseover & no clue they can be interacted with ... is that normal? (do you have an url for the design mockups update?)
should I maybe open a new report about the new items give 0 feedback as being clickable?
(In reply to Sebastien Bacher from comment #5) > The fix makes those less intrusive, but they display as normal text now, no > pointer change on mouseover & no clue they can be interacted with ... is > that normal? (do you have an url for the design mockups update?) It's not specified in the mockups. I'd have expected them to be buttons without relief, so the button background is shown on hover. (In reply to Sebastien Bacher from comment #6) > should I maybe open a new report about the new items give 0 feedback as > being clickable? No objections here...
> No objections here... reported as https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=762690