GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 687986
Use a better shortcut to bring up the messaging bar.
Last modified: 2015-02-27 14:03:00 UTC
With Ctrl+M you'd need both hands for bringing up the bar which can be tedious at times. Can this be changed to Super+Space? If the 'M' is too convinient try thinking of the Space bar as a phisycal message bar. :3
I believe the problem with Super+Space is that it is commonly used to switch input sources.
Indeed, bug #669742 deals with the default shortcut for switching input sources and for me Super+space is the ideal candidate.
FWIW Windows 8 uses Super+V to view notifications. http://www.redmondpie.com/this-extensive-list-of-windows-8-keyboard-shortcuts-will-help-you-adapt-to-the-new-interface/
Any conclusions on this? Changing the default shortcut is obviously trivial, just tell us what it shall be :-) Jakub?
Too bad it's not free to change. Super+M is better mnemonically. But Super+V is more accessible (one handed) and consistency with Windows behavior is a bonus. We might want to phase out super+m in future, but it has pain involved. In addition, I question the need for having an explicit shortcut to expand a currently showing banner. The desired action is dangerously similar and I think the context is king here and I think we should use the same shortcut for expanding the banner and getting to the MT when no banners are shown. But perhaps that's for a separate bug.
(In reply to comment #5) > Too bad it's not free to change. Super+M is better mnemonically. But Super+V is > more accessible (one handed) and consistency with Windows behavior is a bonus. Well, we do support multiple shortcuts per action :-)
Ping?
Messaging redesign is a perfect opportunity for this. I recommend going with <Super>+V, and ditching Super+M as it lost its mnemotechnic aid with the departure of the message tray.
Do we need to do the same kind of transition help we are doing in nautilus for switching shortcuts ? Ie pop up a dialog saying: We see you tried to use Super-M to bring up the _message tray_. You can now use Super-V (a more convenient, one-hand shortcut) to _view notifications_.
Or we could just change the default to ['<super>v', '<super>m'], so that the legacy shortcut just keeps working ...
Created attachment 297938 [details] [review] data: Change default shortcut for opening the message list With the message tray no longer being a distinctive UI element, the existing <super>m shortcut for viewing the notification list is no longer mnemonic. It is also less convenient as it requires both hands with most keyboards. So make <super>v the new default to _view_ notifications, which matches the corresponding Windows default. The previous default is kept as secondary shortcut to ease the transition.
Review of attachment 297938 [details] [review]: I like this, easing these kind of transitions if we can is always a good idea.
Make sure to communicate this to the docs team - there's a page in the docs talking about all the super shortcuts
Attachment 297938 [details] pushed as 58da16c - data: Change default shortcut for opening the message list