GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 599939
1 frame/page Ogg/Theora files
Last modified: 2010-12-22 23:51:58 UTC
Ogg/Theora files created with gstreamer (0.10.25-2) and -base (0.10.25-2ubuntu1) contain all theora frames/packets in separate ogg pages, 1 packet per page, thus causing high container size overhead. For example: Content-Duration: 00:00:50.480 Content-Length: 496.691 kB Content-Bitrate-Average: 80.604 kbps Theora: serialno 2065395012 1040 packets in 1039 pages, 1.0 packets/page, 22.852% Ogg overhead or: Content-Duration: 01:12:40.593 Content-Length: 52.944 MB Content-Bitrate-Average: 101.850 kbps Theora: serialno 0012675979 91006 packets in 91005 pages, 1.0 packets/page, 13.986% Ogg overhead Note, that the pages and packets seem continuous, no gaps, so there shouldn't be a reason to mux a 26 byte frame in a separate ogg page: |2008845077| GP 23057207, packetno 26: 47 bytes |0012675979| page 18026, granulepos 18012|2, Flags: (1 (26)) |0012675979| GP 18012|2, packetno 6: 26 bytes |0012675979| page 18027, granulepos 18012|3, Flags: (1 (38)) |0012675979| GP 18012|3, packetno 7: 38 bytes |0012675979| page 18028, granulepos 18012|4, Flags: (1 (50)) |0012675979| GP 18012|4, packetno 8: 50 bytes |0012675979| page 18029, granulepos 18012|5, Flags: (1 (89)) |0012675979| GP 18012|5, packetno 9: 89 bytes |0012675979| page 18030, granulepos 18012|6, Flags: (1 (123)) |0012675979| GP 18012|6, packetno 10: 123 bytes |0012675979| page 18031, granulepos 18012|7, Flags: (1 (111)) |0012675979| GP 18012|7, packetno 11: 111 bytes
This has been fixed for some time. commit 1701c706ecf449e4ba77ea1a98b007e287439ce8 Author: David Schleef <ds@schleef.org> Date: Tue Mar 9 15:39:55 2010 -0800 oggmux: Don't flush after every frame for theora