Bug 382395 – unable to edit tags

After an evaluation, GNOME has moved from Bugzilla to GitLab. Learn more about GitLab.
No new issues can be reported in GNOME Bugzilla anymore.
To report an issue in a GNOME project, go to GNOME GitLab.
Do not go to GNOME Gitlab for: Bluefish, Doxygen, GnuCash, GStreamer, java-gnome, LDTP, NetworkManager, Tomboy.

Bug 382395 - unable to edit tags


Summary:	unable to edit tags


Status:	RESOLVED DUPLICATE of bug 362876

Product:	rhythmbox
Classification:	Other
Component:	general
Version:	unspecified
Hardware:	Other Linux

Importance:	Normal normal
Target Milestone:	---
Assigned To:	RhythmBox Maintainers
QA Contact:	RhythmBox Maintainers

URL:
Whiteboard:

Depends on:
Blocks:

Reported:	2006-12-04 21:42 UTC by William Jon McCann
Modified:	2006-12-08 03:49 UTC

See Also:
GNOME target:	---
GNOME version:	---

Attachments
output of gst-launch-0.10 -t filesrc location="$1" ! decodebin ! fakesink (1.85 KB, text/plain) 2006-12-05 17:39 UTC, William Jon McCann	Details

Description William Jon McCann 2006-12-04 21:42:49 UTC

I haven't been able to pin down why but I haven't been able to edit tags.  At first I was getting a gstreamer error 'file a bug'.  I think this was due to not having taglib and support in gst-plugins-good.  But now something else...

The tag is changed in the database but not in the file.  Unfortunately --debug isn't giving me much - nor is the metadata helper debug.

Comment 1 William Jon McCann 2006-12-04 22:02:59 UTC

(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_save] rb-metadata-gst.c:1334: saving metadata for uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting title
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting replaygain-track-peak
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting artist
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting replaygain-album-gain
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting album
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting replaygain-album-peak
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting date
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting genre
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting musicbrainz-trackid
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting track-number
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting album-disc-number
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting bitrate
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_add_tag_data] rb-metadata-gst.c:1289: Setting replaygain-track-gain
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_add_id3_tagger] rb-metadata-gst.c:206: using id3v2mux
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [id3_pad_added_cb] rb-metadata-gst.c:163: linked pad from id3de to id3mux
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: title 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: artist 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: album 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: date 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: genre 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: private-id3v2-frame 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: track-number 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: album-disc-number 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp3 tag: image 
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 2048
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:16) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:902: EOS reached
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_load] rb-metadata-gst.c:1018: loading metadata for uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_load] rb-metadata-gst.c:1095: going to PAUSED for metadata, uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_new_decoded_pad_cb] rb-metadata-gst.c:819: got decoded audio pad of type audio/x-raw-int
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_typefind_cb] rb-metadata-gst.c:787: found type application/x-id3
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_load] rb-metadata-gst.c:1103: element state changing asynchronously: 2, 165851784
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_load] rb-metadata-gst.c:1117: gone to PAUSED for file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 512
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: title 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: artist 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: album 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: date 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: genre 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: private-id3v2-frame 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: track-number 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: album-disc-number 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: image 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: genre 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: date 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: album 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: artist 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: title 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: track-number 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: duration 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: bitrate 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: layer 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: mode 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: emphasis 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_gst_load_tag] rb-metadata-gst.c:649: uri: file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736 tag: audio-codec 
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 64
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_bus_handler] rb-metadata-gst.c:948: message of type 16384
(16:57:17) [0x9db3008] [rb_metadata_load] rb-metadata-gst.c:1241: successfully read metadata for file:///home/mccannwj/Music/The%20Rolling%20Stone%20Magazines%20500%20Greatest%20Songs%20Of%20All%20Time/187%20-%20Ac%20Dc%20-%20Back%20In%20Black.mp32C1736

Comment 2 William Jon McCann 2006-12-04 22:07:36 UTC

That was with "Watch library" off.

Comment 3 Jonathan Matthew 2006-12-05 02:57:00 UTC

That all looks normal, except that there appear to be two sets of tags in the file.  'gst-launch-0.10 -t filesrc location=file.mp3 ! decodebin ! fakesink' will tell you where the tags are coming from.

Comment 4 William Jon McCann 2006-12-05 17:39:56 UTC

Created attachment 77740 [details]
output of gst-launch-0.10 -t filesrc location="$1" ! decodebin ! fakesink

Rhythmbox still shows the title as "Back in Black" instead of "The Rolling Stone Magazines 500 Greatest Songs Of All Time".

Comment 5 William Jon McCann 2006-12-07 17:11:09 UTC

Is this a gstreamer bug then?  If I understand this correctly, when I edit the tags it is only changing the ID3v2 ones but when the metadata is reloaded the ones found by apedemux0 take precedence.  This would explain why (when the watch library is on) the tag edit seems to work but then is reverted after the metadata is reloaded in response to the file changed event.

Should we be writing out to the apedemux0 tags too or should the id3demux0 tags take precedence on load?

Comment 6 Alex Lancaster 2006-12-08 03:49:24 UTC

This sounds like the problem in bug #362876 and there is a patch there which converts the APE tags into ID3v2 tags and removes the APE tags.  Closing as a dupe of that bug, feel free to re-open if the bug doesn't cover all the problems there.

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 362876 ***