GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 339683
adding bookmark should act on the selection
Last modified: 2012-08-14 21:34:04 UTC
That bug has been described on https://launchpad.net/distros/baltix/+bug/41256 "I use fresh dapper (2006-04-25) and in my opinion adding to favourites doesn't work properly in nautilus - it is not intuitive and doesn't work as user would expect. Little example: Open Nautilus create ~/test directory go this directory and create two subdirectories: ~/test/1 ~/test/2 Stay in this directory - click on ~/test/2 This directory will be highlighted Then hit Ctrl-D The directory that will be added to favoutites is ~/test not ~/test/2 that we highlighted and we expected to bookmark. In my opinion that's wrong behaviour. Ctrl-D shouldn't work on parent element it should work on currently active and highlighted element. And more - I think that "bookmark" shortcut should be available in context menu on right click. In this way user could select directories that want's to bookmark from his list of visible dirs. For example - I got ~/test dir and ~/test/1 ~/test/2 .... ~/test/100 dirs then I go to ~/test and select directories that I want to bookmark by highlight them and right click + bookmark action on selected dir. Currently to bookmark I should go _into_ directory that I want to bookmark and Ctrl+D. This is non intuitive, time wasting and wrong behaviour. Also bookmarking should work on multiple directories. So I should be able to select directories with mouse click with Ctrl or Shift to select range and then bookmark more than ..."
Confirming, CCing usability team. This is slightly related to bug 326171, which complains that ctrl-v doesn't paste into subfolders. I must say that I agree, I also expected the bookmark feature to act on selected subfolders.
*** Bug 324634 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
This would require relabelling the current 'Add Bookmark' menu entry to something like 'Bookmark Selected Item(s)'.
I agree this was really confusing. We were putting actions in the same menu that operated on the selection and operated on the folder. This is no longer the case in master. Add Bookmark is now a folder action. Which I think is the correct behavior.