GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 145237
parent-folders button does not look like a button
Last modified: 2005-01-27 12:35:57 UTC
Navigating to parent directories in nautius could be a nightmare for new users. The parent-folders button was slagged in an Ars Technica review of Gnome 2.6: "The last critical piece of understanding Nautilus' new behavior is the parent-folders button. While moving into the tree structure is easy, at first, it may not be clear to the user how to go back." Refer to: http://arstechnica.com/reviews/004/software/gnome-2.6/gnome-2.6-2.html This is a usability suggestion that I feel is very important. It is important because novice users will not read the manual to learn about the function of the parent-folders button, and may not try to right click on the background of the window, which provides the option to browse back a directory. So they might be stuck not knowing how to back out of directories, as it's not obvious. The "parent-folders" button in the lower left of each nautilus window does not invite the user to click it. The sunkenness of the parents-folder suggests it's inactive, and just for informational purposes, kind of like the Properties-related data right beside it, (in this screenshot, "151 items, Free space: 64.3 GB") http://www.gnome.org/start/2.6/notes/figures/nautilus-parentfolders.png Therefore I recommend: -the parent-folders button should not be sunken. Sunken implies inactive, informational. It lacks prominence, especially as it's at the bottom of the window. -the parent-folders button should have a small, upward pointing arrow before or after the directory name. This would inform the user: "A useful menu will pop out of me if you click me" -the parent-folders button could have an icon right beside the directory name that is a small folder picture with an arrow pointing right, then up, which is a universally recognized symbol meaning "up a directory". Or, the small folder could have two dots on it, which is a universal UNIX symbol meaning "the parent directory". This ought to be quick and easy to fix.
Created attachment 32229 [details] [review] Patch to fix the problem This patch adds a small relief to the button and places the stock open image in front of the current directory (both on the button and in the popup menu)
Created attachment 32231 [details] Just a quick screenshot of the patch in action
I agree this makes it more easy to spot that this is indeed a button.
I agree. Martin, do you think we can sneak this in? If you think it is low risk, the doc and i18n impact are likely to be low, so the release team would likely be willing to look the other way. Michael: the nautilus maintainers really prefer that patches get sent to nautilus-list@gnome.org. Do you think you could do that? It would help get this in, I'm sure.
Created attachment 36545 [details] [review] updated version of the patch I updated the patch so that it applies to HEAD.
checked in.