GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 132498
Merging down layer with 'screen' filter does strange things.
Last modified: 2004-12-22 21:47:04 UTC
This is probably a bug, or perhaps I don't understand how the 'screen' thing for layers works :) First, make a black (or whatever) backgroundlayer. Say you have 2 transparant layers (on top of that). On one layers a draw a line, and on the other layer as well, so they form an X together. Then I select 'screen' for the upper layer, which still leaves me with an X but where the lines cross it's a bit more bright. Now. When you go image->flatten image, the endresult is 1 layer with the correct image. BUT!, if a) You use merge down on one of he layers, the upper transparant layer disappears. b) you remove or make invisible the black layer, the upper layer disappears as well. Here is an XCF file which demonstrates it. Try to merge down the upper layer, and (undo) and flatten the image. The result should be the same but isn't. http://users.skynet?.be/xterm/xterm/bug.xcf
That URL doesn't work for me. Please correct it.
Sorry, dumb typo. Correct URL. http://users.skynet.be/xterm/bug.xcf
I am not sure if this can be considered a bug. Merging a single layer down is not guaranteed to give the same result. We cannot possibly guarantee this. Your image is a good example of when this is not possible. The upper layer in screen mode affects all non-transparent pixels below it. If you merge it with a single layer it is applied to that layer only and won't affect the transparent areas.
Actually I am sure that this is NOTABUG.