GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 334320
Option to select preffered Subtitle and Audio languages
Last modified: 2006-03-13 11:03:58 UTC
It's not uncommon to have a media file with several subtitle/audio languages which user can select from. These can be DVD, MKV, OGM, but even external subtitle/audio tracks for AVI (and other containers). User should have an option to select which audio and subtitle languages he prefers -- possibly to make some pairs and have certain priority. For example, for me, this priority would be (audio/subs): Japanese/English Japanese/Czech English/NO_SUBS Czech/NO_SUBS */English */Czech Implementing for DVD and MVK should be easy -- for example MKV uses ISO codes to identify languages. There could be some hard time regarding OGM. With external subtitles (for which support in Totem really sucks, because it can't automatically load subs with filenames like "movie_name.lang.srt") and audio tracks (which Totem doesn't support at all, AFAIK): It's kind of de-facto standard that the last word betwen the last pair of fullstops identifies language, like this: movie_name.some.other.words.English.srt For example, VSFilter.dll (favorite DirectShow subtitler filter) would match this subtitle file for movie named "movie_name.mkv", so it can even leave the "some.other.words" part out.
For builtin subtitles (as in DVDs, S-VCDs, Matroska containers, OGM, etc.) it makes sense to use preferred languages. However, I don't plan on adding this feature for text subtitles, as they are missing important information as to the metadata, and it would be in the end, too cumbersome to implement (ie. it would be a gross hack). Thanks for the bug report. This particular bug has already been reported into our bug tracking system, but please feel free to report any further bugs you find. *** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of 166970 ***