GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 169902
It would be nice to have bookmarks...
Last modified: 2008-09-09 10:48:14 UTC
... for very big documents
Laurent: Could you be very specific about the size of the document, what type of document it is. How often you open the document? When you open the document, what are you looking for; where do you go in the document to get the information you need? How do you currently get to where you need in the document? Do you reference a single document for multiple areas? How are you going back and forth to those areas now? In your response please be as explicit as possible. Avoid giving responses where you just say I need a bookmark to jump from here to here as they are not useful. Give a clear example of what you're doing where you believe bookmarks would be nice, but don't indicate why you think they'd be nice. Simply describe the situation in as much detail as possible. I'm going to keep closing requests for a bookmarks system until we get clear ideas on what people are doing. I really need to watch users who are opening and using large documents with a document viewer. If the best I can get is interviews like this I need that, I'm not going to just add any old bookmarks system since I don't want the clutter and I don't think it will solve the problem (if my hunch of what the real problem is true).
I've been working with the PDF 1.6 reference document these days. It's huge: 1236 pages. There are a few parts I often refer to. Although there's an index, since the document is huge, I have to scroll it a lot to find what I'm looking for. With bookmarks, I could go where I want to in 2 key hits.
Nope, I've decided against bookmarks. We have plans to add annotations to Evince and you can use those like bookmarks, they probably will act just like them. However I'm not interested in a separate bookmarking system.
*** Bug 438566 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Hello, Bryan W. Clark wrote over three years ago: > I'm going to keep closing requests for a bookmarks system until we get clear > ideas on what people are doing. I stumbled over this here now. Recently I tried to solve the following use case for us: We run evince as a help file viewer from some application program. Currently we use the command line option --page-label= to jump to a specific section of the help manual to display information related to dialogue of the program in question. It would be very helpful, if the page-label option could use some kind of bookmark or symbolic label instead of a page number. Currently we use a shell script wrapper around evince, which uses a special handcrafted file for each foreign language to translate the label or bookmark into the page number of this PDF file which is than given to evince. Of course this is tedious and cumbersome to maintain. So may be my description of a particular use case makes one of the applications of a bookmark system more clear. Kind regards, Peter Funk
Thanks for your comment, Peter. I really think it's not quite related to bookmarks. Evince can move the view to a certain location (point in index or something like that) with dbus currently, I don't think there is a problem to add an option to do the same from a command line. You just need to generate index in pdf document.
*** Bug 551487 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***