GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 89207
Modemlights apparently doesn't work
Last modified: 2005-01-09 05:57:48 UTC
See https://bugzilla.redhat.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=69971
Ping? What happened to this bug? My fault for not following up on 2.0.1; marking 2.0.2, which'll be tracked better.
What's the status here Havoc? I'm not sure as to what modemlights should be doing by default.
It may well be something that can't be gotten right for all distributions by default, at least not without configure script hackery. I am not much of an expert on this...
An issue in 2.2? If so it needs looking at soon-ish. Marking TARGET 2.2.2.
The two issues are: * Wrong connect commands * No auto-detection of modem lock file I'm not sure but I think that most distros use /sbin/ifup - maybe debian doesnt though, I'll try and find out. As for the lock file - well someone needs to work out how to autodetect which device the modems is and use the corresponding lock file.
Dudes, maintainers: Can someone either a) Fix this applet, or b) Make an executive decision to drop it at some point? This bug isn't getting enough love for something that is apparently entirely broken.
This bug is not a bad as it seems. We've been shipping this applet for years with the same behavior. The problem is that each distribution has different methods for doing ppp, so it wouldn't be that easy to fix, thus it's probably up to the distributions to set the defaults accordingly. Thus I don't see any reason to drop the applet now. Untill there becomes a nice gnome ppp dialer with an applet of it's own, I think we should keep shipping modemlights (I use it myself all the time).
I've asked gnome-love to try and love this applet. Ideally we should be able to get some integration with gnome-system-tools at some point, I'm led to believe it will be supporting ppp in the not too distant future.
My dreams came true. The applet was rewritten to do everything via gnome-system-tools. This bug is by definition no longer an issue.