GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 70976
Vertical toolbars should be mentioned in the HIG
Last modified: 2020-12-04 18:20:48 UTC
I think that vertical toolbars (and proper advice regarding vertical toolbars) should be mentioned in the toolbars section of the HIG.
I added a note on vertical toolbars at: http://developer.gnome.org/projects/gup/hig/draft_hig/toolbars.html#vertical-toolbars However much I tried, though, the best advice I could come up with is "it's almost always better not to use them" :) If anyone has some better advice, feel free to comment....
It was pretty trivial to remove the vertical toolbar from GnomeMeeting. It had far far far more toolbar items than it needed. Not sure its a very good example. Actually, not sure there are any good examples, because my personal feeling is that we should avoid the "toolbar bloat" ala Microsoft Office. At some point toolbars lose their usefulness because they have too many items, and you might as well encourage menu use instead and leave the toolbar for the truly common items. If the user wants to turn on 20 toolbars and make some of them vertical, they can go right ahead, but I don't think applications should have more than one or two, toolbars visible by default.
marking fixed