GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 572171
Out of box deinterlacer is horrible broken
Last modified: 2009-02-26 22:10:11 UTC
Out of box deinterlacer is horrible broken, copy&paste wanted.
Could you be more specific ?
Bad quality of deinterlacing, on moving scenes it produces it own interlacion.
have you tried deinterlace2 ? It's in gst-plugins-bad and is of *much* better quality.
Looks like somehow better, but deinterlacers own interlacion are even more anoying with deinterlace2. I will add screenshot soon.
Created attachment 128971 [details] deinterlace2 screenshot
Have you tried all the available settings that deinterlace2 offers ? Maybe switching the tff setting will improve the quality.
Looks like method=2 tff=0 produces the best results but still have it own interlacion
to be honest... this bug report is going nowhere. How about you attach the file you're using (or give us a link to where we can download it), and then we can actually have a look.
http://torrents.thepiratebay.org/4353553/Death_Note_1_-_20_DVDRip_(Dual_Audio).4353553.TPB.torrent
Could you also attach a screenshot to this bug?
http://bugzilla.gnome.org/attachment.cgi?id=128971&action=view
Ok, I've tried it with any possible deinterlace/deinterlace2 settings and it still looks interlaced. I also tried with mplayer and various deinterlacers and it still looks interlaced... Have you managed to get it properly deinterlaced with *any* software ? If so, could you please tell us with which one ? If not, my guess so far is that it's a bad copy.
The only way to get rid of interlacion for these file for me is to use lvc deinterlacer in blend mode. It's strange, vlc have those quantization lines too in some modes.
Does the deinterlacer know the DPI of monitor?
No it doesn't and can't. You should get the same results as the vlc deinterlace in blend mode if you choose linearblend or vfir. Also try to play with the fields property (top or bottom is probably better in your case instead of all) and the tff property.
I have tried all of them in all combinations, I'm now wathing my interlaced films on my analogue tv heh.
The Main problem is deinterlacers own interlacion, so it deinterlaces in satisfiable manner but produces large 7-10 pixels strips of per frame stripes
Which GStreamer player are you trying all this in?
0.10.21
That's a really useless version number. Which PLAYER are you using? Totem? Something you've written yourself? How are you configuring the deinterlacing for your tests? If you can't provide more information about why it doesn't work for you, we might as well close the bug.
Totem 2.24.3 Im using it throught gconfvideosink. It looks like deinterlace2 method=5 ! xvimagesink device="1"
Oh! looks like a tip that points us on nvidia's xv driver on simple ximagesink I see no more "own" interlacion
Let's close this as NOTGNOME then, sounds like a problem in the nvidia driver...
I think we should try xv trought sdl, to finaly clear gstreamer.