GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 379126
Split transactions: combine multiple entries for one account in one line
Last modified: 2018-06-29 21:17:25 UTC
The basic register view does not really support transactions in which multiple splits reference the same account very well. The current implementation shows a separate line for each split of the transaction, whereas one line for the entire transaction seems (to me) a better approach. Consider the following (long-winded) example: suppose I go to the local computing shop, and buy a number of items for my pc. If I want to have all details of this transaction, I would create one transaction with multiple splits: Local PC farm: -- split transaction --: -300 expense: Wallet: -300 power supply: Computing Expenses: +50 motherboard: Computing Expenses: +100 processor: Computing Expenses: +150 However, when I view the computing expenses account, I see three separate lines: Local PC farm: -- split transaction --: +50 Local PC farm: -- split transaction --: +100 Local PC farm: -- split transaction --: +150 Instead of (what I'd like to see): Local PC farm: -- split transaction --: +300 However, when I select either one of those three lines and expand the split, the transaction amount is changed to +300: Local PC farm: -- split transaction --: +50 Local PC farm: -- split transaction --: +300 expense: Wallet: -300 power supply: Computing Expenses: +50 motherboard: Computing Expenses: +100 processor: Computing Expenses: +150 Local PC farm: -- split transaction --: +150 Also discussed in http://lists.gnucash.org/pipermail/gnucash-user/2006-November/018345.html When this gets accepted (ie not rejected), I might get around to implementing it myself.
Any progress on this one? Split transactions surely could use an upgrade.
This bug seems to have become stagnant since it was first issued over a year ago. I, too, find it irritating that my split transaction appears on multiple lines: this results in entries in my ledger not matching that of my bank account.
Bump for this bug. It makes a basic task (entering multiple deposit items on one transaction) very confusing to one learning gnucash; the result of "correct" entry looks like an error. Further it makes reconciling w/bank statements annoying because it causes a mismatch between displayed transactions and actual transactions recorded on a bank statement. The behavior is completely non-intuitive and actively misleading.
GnuCash bug tracking has moved to a new Bugzilla host. The new URL for this bug is https://bugs.gnucash.org/show_bug.cgi?id=379126. Please continue processing the bug there and please update any external references or bookmarks.