GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 348656
Poor discoverability of the look up process
Last modified: 2006-12-02 16:20:42 UTC
There's no visual cue to let the user understand how to begin the query after having inserted the word inside the entry; it seems that users don't understand that they have to press enter to begin the query. maybe re-instating inside the UI a 'Go'-like button would be in order - with the ability to remove it via a GConf key, so that users who want to have a cleaner UI (like me ;-)) can remove it. Cc-ing usability as their input would be greatly useful.
There is one important use case for the Go-button: middle-click paste. Often when I'm browsing the internet and come across a word I don't reconize, I highlight it and middle-click paste it to the dictionary, but since there is no way to begin the query with the mouse, I have to reach out to the keyboard and press enter. IMHO, the Go-button should be brought back and be visible by default.
Also, if there is going to be a GConf key for hiding the button, please make it a proper button and not one of those annoying flat ones.
Created attachment 72195 [details] [review] add go button This patch adds a go button for the word entry box. It is gconf editable but is shown by default.
I just had an epiphany: the 'Look up:' label can really be a button with no relief (like the link button). since it's the only thing on the dialog, as soon as the user moves the mouse or navigates using the keyboard, will notice the button and will be able to click on it - thus launching the query. even using the mnemonic on the button will achieve the expected result. this should save the appearance (no 'go' button) and add the 'mouse only' support for dictionary.
I've applied the "look up"-as-a-button style to HEAD; could someone look at it and see if's enough or if I have to apply Stephen's patch (thanks, by the way)?
gnome-utils 2.17.1 will ship with the "look up" button. feel free to REOPEN if anyone feels this solution isn't enough.