GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 322296
Oilify plug-in's "Use intensity algorithm" option is superfluous
Last modified: 2005-11-24 16:03:39 UTC
The Oilify plug-in dialog has a checkbox which enables/disables use of the "intensity algorithm," unchecked by default. In practice, when the intensity algorithm is not used (and we are in RGB mode), the resulting "oil painting" image gains numerous stray colors around the edges of normal color areas. Example: http://www.iskunk.org/tmp/oilify/oilify-trippy.jpg I submit that the checkbox is superfluous, because what you get when it is unchecked has little to do with the plug-in's stated purpose of making an image look like an oil painting. (Unless the purpose is to get a "bad acid trip" oil painting.) My suspicion is that this feature is exposed because the non-intensity-mode algorithm (oilify_rgb()) is simpler, was implemented first, and was never removed after its more advanced counterpart (oilify_intensity()) came to be. I think that the plug-in would be better off without oilify_rgb() and that checkbox. If removal of those is not feasible, however, I would at least suggest making "Use intensity" checked by default. The results, I think, are a closer match to what users would expect.
The output looks nice. We should not forget that GIMP is used by artists as well, and not only be people who just try to simulate existing art :)
IMO the toggle button doesn't hurt much and there will definitely be someone missing this feature if we remove it. But I changed the default as you suggested. Closing as FIXED.