GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 151747
cannot associate directories to open with applications
Last modified: 2005-02-09 10:52:19 UTC
There's no open with menu for directories in nautilus 2.7.92 anymore. In 2.7.4 you could associate an application to a directory's open with menu.
This was done on purpose : 2004-08-27 Alexander Larsson <alexl@redhat.com> * src/file-manager/fm-directory-view.c: (can_use_component_for_file), (reset_bonobo_open_with_menu): Don't show the open with menus for folders, nautilus links or when there are multiple items selected. Can you explain why you need to do such a thing ?
I thought it was a useful feature. I had eog, easytag and xmms in the directory's open with menu. You can use it for actions that apply to all files in one directory like viewing all images, tagging all ogg files or adding them to the xmms playlist. I don't understand why it was removed.
This makes sense. Confirming.
The same applies to multiple items. I think it would be very convenient to be able to select, say, 4 mp3 files, right-click on them and choose "Open with xmms".
*** Bug 152984 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
we are agree that it's a convenient feature. So why was it removed ? is there any patch to reactive it ? It's really strange to see the "open with" tab whereas the values are not used ... I think it's just a mistake, so it should be corrected in a future release, shouldn't it ?
Note that this feature can also create problematic situations, e.g. by making it impossible to open folders with nautilus itself (bug 141466). So a middle-ground solution needs to be implemented.
*** Bug 153250 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Wouldn't it then be a good idea, if the standard action for objects of type 'x-directoy/*' would always be 'open in nautilus'?
Any program should be able to add a menu-item to the context menu to do this sort of thing (I think) by installing a nautilus extension. For doing a 'terminal here' sort of thing, you can install nautilus-open-terminal (http://pkg-gnome.alioth.debian.org/debian/pool/n/nautilus-open-terminal/) for which there is not any RPMs yet (but I will be packaging one for fedora3 if no one else does..).
*** Bug 154799 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Matthew: I strongly recomment against packaging that extension. I've actually never fixed any of its leaks. On the bug: While I understand that installing a nautilus extension is an option, simply adding the directory MIME association to your desired application's desktop file is *way* more convenient and will improve DE interoperability. Extensions should in my opinion only be used for more sophisticated actions (making archives, etc.).
Christian, that will not work with folders now. That is the rub.
*** Bug 159190 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Unless this feature gets added again, perhaps it's best to also disable the "Open With"-tab for folders? As it is now, being able to add applications for folders, but not actually use them, is very confusing.
Sven: do you think you could file a separate bug for that? I agree that is irritating.
Filed as bug 162812 http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=162812
I also used this feature regularly and am disappointed to see it gone. It was much more convenient to right-click folders for xmms or easytag than to drag them into xmms (or navigate with easytag). Please consider restoring it.
*** Bug 154847 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Yet more use-cases: gthumb used to associate itself with directories so I could do a slide-show, rotate, etc. Meld associates with directories so you can start meld in CVS mode to view/edit your local changes.
Alex: Maybe you could tell us why you decided to remove this feature. Sometimes I also want to operate on folders with applications different from nautilus.
I don't quite remember the details, but mime registrations for the folder mimetype was causing problems in some way (not letting you open nautilus windows for it or suchlike), so support for that was disabled. I'm not sure why the open-with menu died too though. I can see that being useful for folders, and I can't immediately see why it would break stuff.
right, this is still an issue. Add x-directory/normal to MimeType field, try to open a place in the Places menu in gnome-panel and you get the app instead of nautilus
I enabled the open with menu again.