GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 130662
Incorrect Mime Type Detection for Mr. Project Files and More
Last modified: 2004-12-22 21:47:04 UTC
Mr. Project files on my system are currently identified (by the evils of content sniffing) as xml files. Consequently, they are not openable from nautilus. Grrr... This brings up a potentially bigger usability problem - the current file type system within Gnome is very confusing. And this isn't just the perspective from a dumb linux newbie, this comes from a long-term linux user who just got back to using Gnome for the first time in a couple of years, I mean, I run into the above mentioned problem. I create a Mr. Project file and then try to open it back up. Instead, I get an XML viewer. So I try the standard "Open With..." option that I expect to work. Instead, I get options for configuring the xml mime type. So I check out the advanced desktop preferences where I remember seeing something about file types. Come to find out, the file type for Mr. Project files is configured just fine. This leads me to the unfortunate feeling that Gnome is broken - the kind of feeling that would lead less loyal users to a feeling that Gnome sucks. So I dig around for a while. I think, "Hey, I bet the Gnome Help can help." Well, nope - not at all. All I get is documents taking showing me everything I already saw, all of which seemed to look right, but still was not working right. So I google a bit and discover the EVILS of content sniffing - evil to me simply because EVERYTHING I AS A USER COULD SEE within Gnome was file extension oriented and working correctly. Instead, the file sniffing part was completely undocumented (as far as I could find, and I did look - perhaps I just missed it). And the only way to fix it seems to be to login as root (not something that all users could do) and go fix /etc/gnome-vfs-mime-magic, which is a royal pain. Basically, when it all comes together, my conclusion is that indeed the system IS INDEED broke. And NOT just in some "fix the mrproject mime type" sort of way. Rather, the way that it all is presented to the user is confusing and bad. There's my two cents. Thanks for all of the hard work on Gnome. Overall, the perspective of this "just got back to Gnome" linux user is WOW - this is AWESOME! :) Just wanted to report the problems/usability issues as I ran into them. Thanks, Paul Thompson
Created attachment 23003 [details] incorrectly identified Mr. Project file
2004-01-06 Bastien Nocera <hadess@hadess.net> * gnome-vfs-mime-magic: fix detection of Mr Project/Planner files (Closes: #130662)