GNOME Bugzilla – Bug 84740
The panel needs screenshot, run, search and show desktop button objects
Last modified: 2015-03-24 13:00:35 UTC
Cannot add launcher from Actions menu to Panel via right-click of mouse. If you right click on any Actions menu item the menu item is activated -
I don't think that this is actually a bug, right, Mark?
ping Mark, Luis? I reckon this is a usability bug - should have consitent behaviour accross all panel menus (well that's my take on it).
Okay, this isn't a bug, because the items in that menu aren't specified as .desktop files. I could however be persuaded that we should have run, search and screenshot buttons just like logout and lock buttons. Thoughts usability people ?
i think from an admin perspective making the menu contents configurable would be cool. Only potential problem I can see is that the content of this menu are not in alphabetical order so if you are using .desktop files and try to make it general enough so that admins can change the content of the actions menu this may create some usability issues.
Okay, I'll buy the technical reason for not being able to right click on Actions menu items, but as long as this is the case, right-clicking on these items should probably do nothing rather than activating the item, IMHO. I think the ability to add the buttons to the panel as Mark suggests would also be good, although <obvious>in the longer term we really need more generic and consistent menu interaction/editing behaviour</obvious> :)
ping :)
*** Bug 91606 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Well golly, I'm with Shane on this. There is no reason for an innocent, hapless user to know that there is any distinction between the items in the "Applications" menu, and those in the "Actions" menu. For him (or her) Menu items are menu items, no? When menu items behave inconsistently (as in this example) it becomes more difficult for the user to remember how any given menu item is supposed to work. Dave's technical problem sounded to me like he was focusing on making the items in the Actions menu configurable; that isn't the same as just giving every item there a context menu, is it? Does adding the same context menu to each really cause a technical problem?
Okay guys, I've added extra buttons on HEAD screenshot, search and run. I've also opened another bug, #94120, on the issue of making the actions menu editable. (Note, the fun thing about the way I did this isthat you can change the button action easily between logout, lock, screenshot, search and run now using gconf)
I wonder if the 'action buttons' on the 'Add to panel' menu should go in an "Actions" submenu, rather than being tacked on the bottom of the menu? It's getting quite long...
Yeah, I was going to do that but couldn't find an icon. See #94633.
original problem still present in sun's gnome build fcs-03 - from a users perspective - right-clicking on an item in the Actions menu should not activate that item - this menu should behave as close as possible to the behaviour of the Applications menu for the sake of consistency.
for the sake of mentioning it, right clicking on any menu anywhere else in gnome activates the menu entry. So i see two solutions: 1. Fix gtk so that right clicking on menu entries doesn't activate an item 2. Remove the right click on menu entries from the applications menu (I sort of favor this and find context clicking in menus to be rather odd)
Owen: "Fix gtk so that right clicking on menu entries doesn't activate an item". I suppose it was a design choice. Is there a possibility this will be changed ?
I think all issues in this report have been adressed by now. We have the panel objects and none of these activate if you right click on them as far as I can see.
See bug 116890 for general issues about widget that respond to any button.